What Is the Difference Between ERTC and PPP Loans? 

In the wake of the COVID-19 crisis, federal relief programs like the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) and the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) emerged as lifelines for businesses, especially small businesses, aiming to keep the workforce intact amidst financial turbulence. 

difference between ERTC and PPP Loans

While they may initially appear to be cut from the same cloth, digging a bit deeper reveals the distinct pathways each incentive carves. Understanding the unique attributes of ERTC and PPP loans can empower you to make a well-rounded decision to bolster your business's financial stability. 

What Is the Employee Retention Tax Credit? 

The Employee Retention Tax Credit encouraged businesses to maintain payroll during COVID's peak by providing credits to offset qualified wages and health premiums. Over the years, the program adapted to assist more companies, with the definition of eligible wages expanded and eligibility opened up. 

To claim the credit, companies needed to thoroughly document and report their eligible wages and related health insurance costs every quarter, generally via IRS Form 941 filed along with employment tax returns. Businesses can also amend prior returns to retrieve credits they may have missed originally. 

However, the IRS recently halted new claims starting September 14, 2023 due to suspected fraud. This underscores the critical importance of accurate record-keeping and compliance to successfully benefit from the program. 

What Are Paycheck Protection Program Loans? 

The PPP furnished short-term relief through SBA loans covering mainly payroll expenses. Flexible terms, like a 1% rate and two- to five-year maturity, eased financial stress on small businesses. 

Borrowers that maintained payroll could have their PPP loans converted to non-taxable grants. This forgiveness makes PPP distinct from conventional loans, a lifeline for payroll-heavy small businesses with minimal reserves. 

Applicants were required to submit payroll documentation and other financial details, with precise adherence to SBA rules remaining essential throughout the process. Strict oversight aims to uphold program integrity and prevent abuse. 

Comparative Analysis 

  1. Suitability

    Determining which program aligns better with your company’s particular situation takes careful consideration. For businesses with high payroll expenses, PPP loans based on those costs may provide more substantial, immediate relief. Others faring slightly better but still needing help covering payroll might benefit more from employee retention tax credits spread over upcoming quarters.Additionally, some non-profits and unique entities may find that the ERTC’s structure accommodates their needs when PPP loans do not. Carefully assessing your operations, finances and workforce is imperative in weighing the optimal match.

  2. Financial Implications

    Both programs carry major financial upsides, but through different mechanisms. The ERTC directly lowers tax burdens, saving money over time through credits. This enables smoother financial planning. Meanwhile, PPP loans provide rapid cash flow, which can be more critical for firms experiencing intense distress. Loan forgiveness, when secured, delivers completely non-taxable money.  However, timing forgiveness correctly hinges on strict adherence to the rules. The ERTC involves fewer moving parts in that regard. With competent tax guidance, claiming credits is relatively straightforward.

  3. Flexibility and Accessibility

    For quick relief, the PPP application process generally proves more straightforward than navigating the specialized ERTC rules. Its forgiveness element also allows for flexibility in usage of funds. However, the ERTC sustains support across quarters, which could benefit long-term resilience.Recently tightened IRS scrutiny of ERTC claims presents a hurdle that businesses must clear to access the credits. This underscores the value of experienced tax guidance when pursuing this program.

Maximizing Benefits with Both Programs 

Legally, it is technically possible for businesses to utilize both programs in tandem. However, there are strict guidelines in place to prevent “double dipping” or duplicating benefit claims. If you’re interested in leveraging both the ERTC and PPP program, expert tax guidance is essential. 

For example, payroll covered by PPP loan spending cannot be included for ERTC credits. Careful record-keeping and allocation of expenses is key. Regular consultation with tax and finance advisors ensures compliance and optimized application timing. 

One common approach businesses take when utilizing both incentives is using PPP to cover immediate payroll needs during revenue drops while claiming ERTC credits for additional qualified expenses in subsequent quarters. This sustains employment further than either program alone could. 


Navigating the difference between ERTC and PPP loans involves understanding their distinct advantages and limitations in relation to your business’s unique situation. Having expert guidance can prove invaluable for harnessing the full financial benefits responsibly. 

At Engineered Tax Services (ETS), our advisors offer customized guidance on strategically utilizing programs like the ERTC and PPP to stabilize your finances. We invite you to contact us for tailored solutions addressing your particular needs and long-term objectives. 


Engineered Tax Services

Engineered Tax Services

Recent Posts

cost segregation for hotels

How Cost Segregation for Hotels Drives Profitability

In the hospitality industry, every strategy that leads to operational efficiency and financial stability is worth exploring. Among these, cost segregation stands out as a beacon for hotel owners. Hotels encompass a wide array of assets—ranging from luxurious furnishings to advanced kitchen equipment—all of which depreciate at different rates. Harnessing the power of cost segregation

Read More »

Can You Amend a Tax Return to Take Bonus Depreciation?

Let’s face it, no one wants to pay more taxes than they absolutely have to, especially when every dollar counts towards your business’s growth and stability. One often-overlooked tax savings opportunity is bonus depreciation, an IRS-approved tax strategy that allows you to deduct a large portion of asset costs in the first year. If you’ve

Read More »

179D vs. 45L Tax Credits: A Comparative Look at Energy Tax Incentives

When it comes to making homes and buildings more energy efficient, tax credits and deductions can provide helpful financial incentives. Two major options are the 179D tax deduction for commercial buildings and the 45L tax credit for residential properties. But how do these two programs compare? Let’s take a closer look. The Core Idea The

Read More »

Contact Us